The “secret museums”: when erotic antiquity was locked away
Partager
In the nineteenth century, two great capitals of learned antiquity chose the same solution: to set aside, in a reserved room, the objects judged too daring for the public. In Naples, the Gabinetto Segreto takes shape in 1819. In London, the Secretum of the British Museum is officially founded in 1865. These cabinets tell us as much about the prudery of their time as about Rome. They recount a way of locking the past away, and the misunderstanding that follows.
A separate room, in Naples
The first finds described as “somewhat obscene”, in the cities around Vesuvius, were at first shown without restriction at the Museum Herculanense in Portici. The embarrassment, however, comes early. The booklet of the Museo Archeologico Nazionale in Naples, written by Antonio Coppa, notes that a room reserved for “obscene” antiquities is documented at Portici as early as 1794. David Gaimster, in History Today in 2000, places in 1795, in that same museum, a Room XVIII accessible only with a special permit. The two dates are close; they do not quite coincide. What is clear is the gesture: to separate.
In February 1819, the crown prince Francis, the future Francis I, visits the museum — by then transferred to Naples — with his wife María Isabel and their daughter Luisa Carlota, aged nine. According to the MANN booklet, he suggests that it would be well to lock away all the obscene objects, of whatever material, in a room which only persons of mature age and recognised morals would enter. The suggestion has the force of an order. On the first floor is arranged the “Gabinetto Segreto degli oggetti osceni”, which in 1823 becomes the cabinet “of reserved objects”.
How many objects, at the first inventory? Here the sources diverge, and that must be said. From a catalogue drawn up by the director Michele Arditi, the MANN booklet gives one hundred and two “infamous monuments of pagan licence”. Gaimster, relying on a contemporary guide, gives the figure of two hundred and two “abominable monuments of human licentiousness”. We will not decide between them. The important point lies elsewhere: these objects had already been classified apart, under a moral label, even before they had all been studied.
The legend of the wall, and what the archive says
Far from stifling curiosity, the reserve excites it. Both sources agree on the attendance figures: in 1822, only twenty requests for authorisation in the year; two years later, more than three hundred. The MANN booklet adds that attendants sometimes sold forged permits. In 1851, after the failure of the hopes born in 1848, the director Spinelli di Sangiorgio has the collection moved into two storerooms; the door is walled up, Giuseppe Fiorelli relates, in order to “dissipate the memory of it as far as possible”.
When Garibaldi enters Naples, in September 1860, he orders the reopening, except for children. The museum booklet specifies that women and the clergy still had to have a special authorisation. A colourful account, due to the German writer Gustav Rasch, long spoke of a heroic liberation, with walls being knocked down. The MANN booklet, relying on a report of 11 September 1860, shows something else: no wall was demolished. The rooms were closed by a grille with three locks. The keys could not be found; it was decided to force the doors. The legend speaks of the desire for a spectacular rupture. The archive speaks of a bolt, and an order.
Fiorelli, once he has become director, publishes in 1866 a catalogue of the collection, which he calls “pornographic”. He judges that not all the objects were truly obscene, and that several could rejoin their original collections “without offending decency”. This is the beginning of a scholarly classification. It does not prevent later closures: in April 1901, under Ettore Pais; then, under fascism, an even tighter authorisation regime, while the Lupanar of Pompeii is closed in 1931. After the war, the collection numbers more than two hundred and fifty works. According to the MANN, it reopens without restriction only in 2000.
In London, an official Secretum
The same reflex reaches the British Museum. Gaimster recalls that antiquities were already being set aside there, on grounds of “obscenity”, from the late 1830s. The Secretum takes on its official status in 1865, in the wake of the British Obscene Publications Act of 1857, with the gift of George Witt: four hundred and thirty-four objects presented as “symbols of the primitive worship of mankind”. The trustees accept the gift. Pieces of very diverse origin are thus brought together, under a single key, detached from their context, in the name of a single moral category.
Gaimster puts it clearly: these cabinets are a laboratory for studying public sensibility, even more than antiquity itself. What the nineteenth century did not know how to show, it put away. By isolating sex, it partly invented the “obscene” object as a class apart, fit for duly authorised scholars, dangerous for others. The MANN booklet confirms this in its own way: certain mythological paintings, scarcely sexual by today’s standards, had been relegated there by a moralism impatient of the nude.
What these rooms teach us
The secret museums do not erase the ancient images. They tell, above all, the story of the moment when it was decided that those images could no longer live alongside the rest. Naples and London did not merely “hide” phalluses, frescoes, amulets. They constructed a gaze: that of an age which wanted to admire Rome without accepting all of its images, and which, in doing so, sometimes misread what it locked away — a sign of happiness, a banquet scene, an object of protection, as well as an erotic scene.
Today, many of these works have joined a more open itinerary, or at least a more fully explained one. The lesson remains. An ancient object becomes obscene only in the gaze that classifies it. If this history makes you want to look differently at what is shown, or at what one offers oneself, the Selfgasm shop welcomes that curiosity without a reserved cabinet, and without making a secret of it.
Sources
- Antonio Coppa, « Gli "infami monumenti" del Gabinetto Segreto. Storia di una collezione », booklet of the Museo Archeologico Nazionale di Napoli. MANN booklet (PDF)
- David Gaimster, « Sex and Sensibility at the British Museum », History Today, vol. 50, no. 9, September 2000. History Today
Photo: entrance of the Gabinetto Segreto at the Museo Archeologico Nazionale in Naples, photograph by Jebulon, CC0 1.0, via Wikimedia Commons.