When the face massager concealed a sex toy
Partager
In the early twentieth century, vibrators were bought from general-interest magazines, as one might buy a hair straightener or a piece of gymnastic equipment. They promised to erase wrinkles, soothe a headache, restore health. Their intimate use was almost never named, even though it was already known. This history of camouflage is real. It has nothing to do, however, with the often repeated story of Victorian doctors who supposedly “treated hysteria” with these devices.
First, setting a myth aside
In 1999, the historian Rachel Maines popularised the idea that, in the nineteenth century, doctors had used vibrators to induce female orgasms as a form of treatment. The story circulated as a fact, to the point of inspiring a play and a film. In 2018, Hallie Lieberman and Eric Schatzberg reread the sources cited by Maines. They did not find that proof there. We have already addressed this point in a separate article, and the dossier deserves to be kept distinct. It needed to be recalled here, because the modern history of sex toys often begins, wrongly, with that consulting-room scene.
The documented history is both simpler and more interesting. It is played out less in the hospital than in advertising.
From the consulting room to the home
According to Lieberman, the British physician J. Mortimer Granville is credited with the invention of the electromechanical vibrator in the early 1880s. He intended it for the treatment of nervous disorders, in men as in women. In his writings, Granville is not unaware that the device can have sexual uses; that is not, however, how he presents it, nor how he first sells it.
The shift occurs when the object leaves the consulting room for the catalogue. Lieberman notes, as early as 1899, in the American magazine McClure’s, an advertisement for the Vibratile vibrator, presented as a beauty and health device, able to “remove wrinkles” and “cure nervous headache”. Within a few years, the tone is set: there is no talk of pleasure. There is talk of skin, nerves, fitness.
A market that says everything, except the word
By the early twentieth century, this market was no longer a confidential curiosity. Lieberman notes that, by 1909, at least some twenty American manufacturers were offering similar devices, among them the Arnold Vibrator Company, Eureka, Hygeia, Lindstrom Smith and the Swedish Vibrator Co. Between 1905 and 1920, more than sixty vibrator patents were issued in the United States. The McGraw Electrical Directory lists thirty-four manufacturers in 1909; the EMF Electrical Yearbook counts thirty-one in 1921. A single one of them, Star, is said to have sold 800,000 devices in 1921. Lieberman notes that Star was not the most widespread brand, which suggests that annual sales ran into the millions.
How to sell such an object in a country where obscenity laws were strict, and where masturbation remained an acknowledged taboo? By giving it another name, and another setting. The advertisements appeared in The New York Times and Scientific American, were displayed in tramways, and addressed grandparents as well as young parents. The discourse is openly asexual. At the same time, Lieberman emphasises, certain images, and above all certain phallic attachments that were screwed onto the device, hinted at an entirely different use. The face massager is not always only a face massager. It can become one for the length of a sentence, in a catalogue. It can cease to be one as soon as the attachment is changed.
Speaking of sex openly remains rare, and risky. According to Lieberman, cited in 2018 by the BBC, a 1903 advertisement for a Hygeia device already presents it as a sexual accessory intended for men and women. This kind of admission is the exception, not the rule. For decades, camouflage remained the safest way to circulate the object.
What this camouflage tells us
This strategy is not an amusing detail in the history of advertising. It says something lasting about the way modern societies have treated pleasure: by making it visible under another label, rather than by acknowledging it. It also explains why it is still so easy, even today, to project onto these devices a medical history older and more spectacular than it in fact was. The early-twentieth-century vibrator does not need Victorian doctors in order to exist. It needs catalogues, shop windows, and a language of health broad enough to contain everything, including what cannot be written down.
The objects later changed name, form and discourse. In the second half of the twentieth century, they would gradually appear as what they also are: sex toys. That emergence from camouflage is another story, which can be told separately. What matters, for this one, is the initial gesture: selling pleasure by speaking first of the face, of wrinkles, of the nerves.
Today, a vibrator or a massager no longer needs to pass itself off as a beauty accessory. One can choose an object for what it is, in a safe material, with a clear description. If this genealogy makes the gesture more legible, the Selfgasm shop makes it possible to look through these objects as they now present themselves: without detour, and without making a secret of them.
Sources
- Hallie Lieberman, « Selling Sex Toys: Marketing and the Meaning of Vibrators in Early Twentieth-Century America », Enterprise & Society, 2016. Cambridge University Press
- Hallie Lieberman and Eric Schatzberg, « A Failure of Academic Quality Control: The Technology of Orgasm », Journal of Positive Sexuality, vol. 4, no. 2, 2018. Article (PDF)
- Melissa Hogenboom, « The vibrator: from medical tool to revolutionary sex toy », BBC Future, 8 November 2018, which cites Hallie Lieberman, notably on the 1903 Hygeia advertisement. BBC Future
Photo: advertisement for the White Cross Electric vibrator, New-York Tribune, 5 January 1913, public domain (United States), via Wikimedia Commons.